One of the biggest issues that Sunnis have with Shias is their belief regarding their Imams concerning hidden knowledge. By simply going through Al-Kafi we find chapters that suggest that the Imams had knowledge of Ghayb and that they know when they will die. This extremeness in Shiasm is due to such narrations. However, when we look into Nahul-Balagha, we find a very human Ali that clearly had no super-human knowledge.
The historical evidence that supports this can be found in Sermon #31 where Ali sends Ibn Abbas to the army of Basra, he advises Ibn Abbas, “Don’t meet Talha, for he is like a bull that had readied its horns. He rides the wild (mounts) while claiming that they are docile. However, meet Al-Zubair, for he is easy-going.”
Note: Shias reading this will probably argue that Ali was doing this in order to establish the proof upon them. However, we only find Ali attempting to reconcile through Al-Zubair. This is proof that he was sincerely seeking reconciliation, but was not able to reach that goal. If he had knowledge of the inevitability of the tragedy of Al-Jamal, he would not have even attempted to send Ibn Abbas to Al-Zubair in the first place.
In a very clear Letter #47 (286) Ali tells Al-Hasan and Al-Hussain after he is stabbed by Ibn Muljam, “If I die from this strike, then strike him with one strike, and do not disfigure him.”
These words imply that he was not sure if he was going to die from the wound or not. This firmly contradicts Shia ideology regarding the knowledge of Ali.
Moreover, in Sermon #126, he speaks about a prophecy. A man exclaims, “O’ Commander of the Believers, you have been given the knowledge of the unseen.” Ali laughs then responds by saying, “The knowledge of the unseen is the hour and what occurs therein, as He – praise be to Him – said, “To Allah is the knowledge of the hour.” Allah – praise be to Him – knows what is in the uterus, whether male or female, attractive or ugly, generous or stingy, in hellfire as fuel or in the heavens with the prophets as companions. This is the knowledge of the unseen that is not known by anyone other than Allah, and apart from that is knowledge that Allah taught his prophet who taught me. He then supplicated that my chest grasps it and that my ribs contain it.”
It should be noted that the Prophet – peace be upon him – had to supplicate for Ali to memorize and understand matters of future events that he taught him. This too contradicts Shia ideologies that suggest that the Imams cannot forget.
Ali’s knowledge is not super-human. His knowledge was limited to what he was taught by the Prophet – peace be upon him – who did not teach him about all the matters of the future. This is clear observed in his own words above.
1. Sermon #5 “…I have hidden knowledge, if I disclose it you will start trembling like ropes in deep wells”.
What kind of hidden knowledge Hadrat Ali ibn Abi Talib is talking about in this sermon?
Wa alaykum alsalam. The fifth sermon is weak. See this link for gradings: http://nahjul-balagha.net/sermons-1-80/